How Should a Dog Collar Fit

A dog’s collar is one of the most important equipment an owner needs to choose. Getting the right fit ensures your furry friend’s comfort and safety. But with so many options out there, how do you know which collar is best and that it fits properly? This guide will cover everything you need to know about dog collar types, sizing, fitting, and more.

Choosing the proper dog collar is essential for any pup parent. An ill-fitting collar can lead to escaped dogs, neck injuries, and general discomfort. Alternatively, a well-fitted collar keeps your dog secure and comfortable while also allowing freedom of movement.

The key to a great fit is understanding your dog’s unique neck circumference and collar needs. You’ll also want to learn about different collar types and materials. By taking the time to find the right size and style, you can ensure your dog’s collar does its job properly.

In this guide, we’ll cover:

  • Different types of dog collars and materials
  • How to measure your dog’s neck for a proper fit
  • The two-finger rule for testing tightness
  • Adjusting martingale and slip collars
  • Checking collar fit regularly as your dog grows
  • FAQs about getting the right collar fit

Follow these tips and your dog will enjoy maximum comfort and safety with their collar. A snug but not too tight fit around the neck is what you should aim for. So let’s get started on picking the perfect collar for your furry friend!

Types of Dog Collars

There are many types of dog collars available to choose from. The collar you select should suit your dog’s breed, size, and purpose. Here are some of the most common options:

Flat Collars

Flat collars, often made of nylon or leather, are the most popular everyday walking and identification collar. They easily clip on and fasten with a buckle or plastic clip. Flat collars come in various widths, so measure your dog’s neck to find the right fit. Wider collars distribute pressure better for pulling dogs.

Martingale Collars

Martingale collars are made of two loops joined with a tightening mechanism. This enables the collar to lightly tighten if the dog tries to back out of it prevent escapes, while not choking the dog when pulled forward. They are often used for training and walking dogs that slip out of regular collars.

Slip Collars

Slip collars tighten around the dog’s neck when you pull on the leash correction during training. They should only be used for short periods to avoid choking hazards. Proper fitting and use is essential.

Head Collars

Head collars fit around a dog’s muzzle and head to give you steering control for dogs that pull hard on leashes. They should not be used to tie dogs up. Introduce head collars slowly with treats and praise to get your dog comfortable wearing one.

Padded Collars

Padded dog collars provide extra cushioning and distribute pressure gently, making them more comfortable for dogs. They help protect the trachea from straining against flat collars. Fluffy or long-haired dogs can benefit from padded collars.

When selecting a collar type, think about your dog’s size, breed, purpose, and temperament. The collar size also needs to be right for proper fit and function.

How Tight Should a Dog Collar Be? The Two Finger Rule

Finding the sweet spot between too tight and too loose is key for your dog’s collar fit. If you can comfortably slip two fingers underneath the collar, it’s fitted properly. The two-finger test ensures:

  • The collar is snug enough not to slip off over the head but also loose enough not to constrict the neck. You should be able to rotate it around the neck easily.
  • Your dog can swallow and breathe normally. The collar shouldn’t be tight enough to cause gagging, choking or coughing when on.
  • Blood circulation isn’t restricted. A too-tight collar digs into the skin and pushes on the trachea. Two fingers’ space prevents this.
  • Prevents matted fur and chafing. The extra room keeps the collar from rubbing and allows air to circulate.

Check for a proper fit by sliding two fingers under the collar at your dog’s throat and gently pulling. You should have room to move your fingers back and forth. If not, loosen the collar a notch or two.

Collar Size and Fit: Fitting a Dog Collar Properly

Measuring your dog’s unique neck circumference is key for finding the right collar size. Here’s how to get the perfect custom fit:

Step 1: Measure the Neck

Use a soft measuring tape to measure around your dog’s neck where a collar normally sits. Keep their head in a natural position. For accuracy, record inches and the nearest half inch (i.e. 11.5 inches).

Step 2: Determine the Right Size

Consult a collar size chart to identify the correct size based on your dog’s neck measurement. Allow room for growth if your dog is a puppy. It’s better for collars to be slightly big to enable adjusting as needed.

Step 3: Check the Fit

Once you’ve selected a collar in the matching size, fasten it and perform the two finger test. Make sure you can slide two fingers between the collar and your dog’s neck. The collar shouldn’t be constricting.

Step 4: Adjust and Monitor

Use the buckle, clasp, or slides to slightly loosen or tighten the collar until your dog appears comfortable. Check the fit regularly as your puppy grows into their collar.

Getting an accurate measurement and using the two finger rule allows you to achieve a fitted but not too tight collar. Monitor the fit and keep your dog comfortable as they grow into their perfect collar.

Understanding Martingale Dog Collar Fit

Martingale collars deserve special mention when discussing proper fit. They consist of a large loop that tightens slightly when leash pressure is applied. This makes them ideal for training dogs that slip out of regular collars but pose choking risks if fitted incorrectly.

How Martingales Work

Martingales have an adjustable loop at the back that tightens up to a certain point when pulled against. This tightening applies gentle pressure to discourage your dog from backing out but doesn’t constrict the airway.


  • Prevents escape artists from slipping their collars
  • Provides control without choking hazards
  • Can be loosened fully for comfort when not training


  • Requires proper measurement and fitting like all collars
  • Should only tighten snugly, not restrict breathing
  • Check to be sure the collar isn’t too tight when tightened fully
  • May not be suitable for all breeds and temperaments

It’s important to learn how to fit a martingale collar correctly. Adjust so you can get two fingers under the large loop and the sliding loop moves freely. Your dog should never gasp for air. Introduce slowly and use only for short training periods.

The Importance of Regularly Checking dog Collar Fit

Like humans, dogs grow and their necks change size over time. As a caring dog owner, you’ll want to monitor collar fit regularly. Keeping an ill-fitting collar on a growing puppy is uncomfortable and dangerous.

Schedule monthly checks of your dog’s collar, especially during growth spurts under age two. Look for:

  • Difficulty slipping two fingers between collar and neck
  • Irritated skin, fur loss, or sores on the neck
  • Coughing or gagging when the collar is tugged
  • Collar sitting too low or riding up on the neck

If your dog shows signs of an improper fit, immediately adjust or size up their collar accordingly. Growing into a collar is normal but allowing one to remain too tight can damage the trachea.

Err on the side of a looser fit for your dog’s comfort and safety. And be vigilant about regular collar checks. Your furry friend relies on you for their wellbeing. Keeping their collar properly fitted as they grow is an essential responsibility.

FAQ About Dog Collar Fit

Below are answers to some common questions dog owners have about getting the right collar fit:

How often should I check my dog’s collar fit?

Check the tightness at least once per month by using the two finger test. Puppies under age two and rapidly growing dogs need more frequent checks.

My dog’s collar is getting tight. What should I do?

Immediately size up to the next size collar if their current one is getting tight. Leaving a snug collar on risks hurting their neck.

How do I know if a collar is too loose?

If you can fit more than two fingers under the collar, it is likely too loose. Your dog may be able to slip out of it and escape.

My dog pulls a lot on walks. What collar is best?

Try a front clip harness or head collar to gain control of dogs that pull heavily on the leash without choking. Proper training can also help address pulling.

Conclusion About Dog Collar Fit

Finding the right dog collar and fit for your furry friend is an important responsibility. Now that you know about the various collar types and materials, how to accurately measure your dog’s neck, and tips for achieving the ideal snug but not too tight fit, you can ensure your pup’s comfort and safety. Be sure to regularly check the sizing as your dog grows and don’t hesitate to adjust accordingly. A properly fitted collar allows your dog the freedom to move and play while keeping them securely leashed for walks. And it prevents neck injuries caused by excessive constriction. By following this guide, you can equip your dog with a collar both of you will love. Ultimately, choosing the right size and fit comes down to understanding your dog’s needs and prioritizing their health and happiness.

Leave a Comment